Nostalgic
Filters
-
Lifesavers Swirled Lollipops 7.1oz bag
Spangler Candy Co.Original price $4.99Current price $4.00| /Swirl pops are back! Gone for over a decade these delicious cream swirled pops licensed by Mars Wrigley are now being produced by Spangler Candy Co...
View full detailsOriginal price $4.99Current price $4.00| / -
Anderson's Red Peanut Rounder 2.25oz pack or 30ct box
Anderson Candy Cofrom $1.39| /A Staple Item in The South West! Anderson Candy uses only the finest roasted peanuts in every rounder they produce!
from $1.39| / -
Sugar Babies Caramel Apple 4.75oz box or 12ct case
Charms Candy Co.from $1.99| /Enjoy bite-sized, milk caramel goodness with Sugar Babies, America's favorite chewy caramel treat. Introduced in 1935 in response to the success of...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Candy Cigarettes Original 24ct Box or .72oz Pack
World Confectionsfrom $0.89| /The Original being produced since the late 19th Century! It has been a classic candy item and a bit of a controversary item as well. Agree or disag...
View full detailsfrom $0.89| / -
Gimbals Cinnamon Lovers 7oz bag
Jelly Belly Candy Company$4.39| /Gimbals Candy since 1898. These Cinnamon Lovers are heart shaped gourmet jelly beans that are sure to delight your taste buds and sizzle your sense...
View full details$4.39| / -
Fun Dip .43oz pack or 48ct box
Ferrara Candy Companyfrom $0.59| /Originally called Lik-m-aid by Sunline Brands (formerly Willy Wonka Brands) This amazing iconic candy goes back to 1959! A product of Pixy Stix, Li...
View full detailsfrom $0.59| / -
Sugar Daddy 1.7oz pop or 24ct box
Tootsie Roll Industriesfrom $2.19| /Enjoy satisfying, milk caramel goodness with Sugar Daddy, America's oldest and most popular milk caramel lollipop. Slow-cooked caramel, packed in n...
View full detailsfrom $2.19| / -
Necco Wafers Original 2oz pack or 24ct box
Spangler Candy Co.from $1.99| /Originally manufactured in 1847 by Necco (New England Confectionery Company in Massachusetts) After Necco, the oldest know USA Candy Manufacture cl...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Abba Zaba Snack Size Bars 4.4oz bag or 12ct Case
Annabelle Candy Cofrom $3.59| /A Soft n Chewy Taffy with a delicious roasted Peanut Butter Filled Center, Abba Zaba May just be your only friend, If you don't share nicely!
from $3.59| /Sold out -
Smarties Candy Necklace .74oz pack or 24ct box
Smarties Candy Co.from $0.69| /The Original Classic, this is a staple candy in American confectionery, delicious candy beads strung on a one size fits most elastic string, wear i...
View full detailsfrom $0.69| / -
Bit O Honey 4.2oz bag or 12ct Case
Spangler Candy Companyfrom $2.79| /With Real Honey & Almond Bits blended into taffy, Bit-O-Honey is an American Icon for almost 100 years! Originally Introduced in 1924 by Schutt...
View full detailsfrom $2.79| / -
Big Hunk Snack Size 4.4oz bag or 12ct case
Annabelle Candy Cofrom $3.59| /Just like the original classic, this bag is packed with Big Hunks of Honey Sweetened chewy Nougat with whole Fresh Roasted Peanuts, that you know a...
View full detailsfrom $3.59| /Sold out -
Tart n Tinys 1.5oz pack or 24ct box
Leaf Brands LLCfrom $1.99| /Gone for over a decade, these amazing little candy bites are back! In a variety of flavors, get ready to pucker up buttercup!
from $1.99| /Sold out -
Zotz Blue Raspberry Orange Grape 4pc strip or 48ct box
Andre Prost Inc.from $0.69| /Since 1970 Zotz have been bringing the FIZZ Power direct from Italy! This box contains Blue Raspberry Orange and Grape Fizz filled hard candies! Ov...
View full detailsfrom $0.69| / -
Pop Rocks Strawberry .33oz pack or 24ct box
Pop Rocks, Inc.from $1.39| /Pop Rocks, Poppin Since 1970! These Carbonated Crystals were so popular when introduced that an urban legend was born stating that if you consumed ...
View full detailsfrom $1.39| / -
Sugar Daddy Mini pop or 48ct box
Tootsie Roll Industriesfrom $0.40| /Enjoy small satisfying, milk caramel goodness with Sugar Daddy, America's oldest and most popular milk caramel lollipop. Slow-cooked caramel, packe...
View full detailsfrom $0.40| / -
Big Hunk 1.8oz bar or 24ct box
Annabelle Candy Cofrom $1.99| /Behold, A Big Hunk of Honey Sweetened chewy Nougat with whole Roasted Peanuts. I will definitely take a full box please!
from $1.99| /Sold out -
Whatchamacallit 1.6oz bar or 36ct Box
Hershey Chocolate Companyfrom $1.99| /Its delicious, what should we call it? Peanut Crisp Bar? Chocolate Caramel Crisp? PCC Bar? Choco caramello crispy peanut bar? What ever you want to...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Caramel Creams Oreo 1.9oz pack
Goetzes Candy Co.$1.59| /Also known as Bulls-Eyes, The original Goetze's Caramel Creams, soft chewy caramel with a smooth cream center, but the Oreo cookie version!
$1.59| /Sold out -
Wax Lips .5oz pack or 24ct box
Charms Candy Co.from $1.99| /Wack O Wax Classics Pucker up with these cherry flavored wax lips, Fun for any occasion! Play now, Chew later
from $1.99| / -
Gold Mine Gum 2oz pack or 24ct box
SP Enterprises, Inc.from $2.39| /Unearth a sweet surprise with Gold Mine Gum! These classic burlap sacks are filled with "nugget" bubble gum that's sure to satisfy your cravings. P...
View full detailsfrom $2.39| / -
Big Cherry 1.75oz bar or 24ct box
Adams & Brooks Inc.from $1.99| /Christopher's Big Cherry Bar, Chocolate, Peanuts, and a Whole Cherry in the center. ***IMPORTANT NOTICE: We are not responsible for melted chocol...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Cow Tales Original 1oz pack or 36ct box
Goetzes Candy Co.from $0.59| /Chewy caramel rope with a delicious cream center, one bite of this cows tail and it will have you Moo-ing for more!
from $0.59| / -
Candy Buttons .5oz pack or 24ct box
Doscher's Candy Co.from $1.79| /These go way back and may be one of the most iconic candies around, Originally made by Necco, Now the great folks at Doschers Candy Co in Ohio are ...
View full detailsfrom $1.79| /