Nostalgic
Filters
-
Junior Mints 1.84oz pack or 24ct box
Tootsie Roll Industriesfrom $1.49| /Creamy Peppermint wrapped in pure semi sweet chocolate! ***IMPORTANT NOTICE: We are not responsible for melted chocolate. Must be shipped with ic...
View full detailsfrom $1.49| / -
Goldenberg Peanut Chew 2oz bar or 24ct box
Just Born Inc.from $1.99| /Since 1917, These chewy, chocolatey bites loaded with crunchy peanuts, was originally served as a WWI ration bar! Proudly continuing this delicious...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| /Sold out -
Daily C Strawberry 5.3oz bag
Iconic Candy Co.$3.49| /Experience the revitalizing powers of vitamin C with Daily C Strawberry Tabs! The Original was Daily C Orange Dating back to the late 1800's when S...
View full details$3.49| / -
Daily C Orange 5.3oz bag
Iconic Candy Co.$3.49| /Experience the revitalizing powers of vitamin C with Daily C Orange Tabs. Dating back to the late 1800's when Smith Brothers originally produced, F...
View full details$3.49| / -
Silly Stix 40ct bag
World Confections$2.29| /Introducing Silly Stix! Remember the Wonka Pixy Sticks from back in the day? Well, those may be factory discontinued but Candy lovers Rejoice! Sill...
View full details$2.29| / -
Red Vines Original Super Ropes 2oz Rope or 10ct Pack
American Licorice Companyfrom $1.99| /Indulge in the iconic taste of Red Vines Original Super Ropes! Weather your at Home enjoying a movie, or at the baseball game, These babies measure...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Sour Punch Bites Pickle Roulette 5oz Bag
American Licorice Company$2.19| /Taste the excitement with Sour Punch Bites! Featuring everything you loved about Pickle Roulette Straws, these Pickle Roulette Bites will star-stri...
View full details$2.19| / -
Sour Punch Bites Blue Raspberry 5oz Bag
American Licorice Company$2.19| /Taste the excitement with Sour Punch Bites! These Tart Blue Raspberry chewy candies pack a punch with bold flavors and bright colors. Designed for ...
View full details$2.19| / -
Mike and Ike Watermelon .78oz pack or 24ct box
Just Born Inc.from $0.33| /Mike and Ike Watermelon, same exact texture as the original but this is for the Watermelon Lovers in the world, All Watermelon and only Watermelon ...
View full detailsfrom $0.33| / -
Mike and Ike Cherry .78oz pack or 24ct box
Just Born Inc.from $0.33| /Mike and Ike Cherry, same exact texture as the original but this is for the Cherry Lovers in the world, All Cherry and only Cherry inside this deli...
View full detailsfrom $0.33| / -
Stuckeys Old Time Peanut Brittle 6oz Bag
Stuckey's Corporation$5.99| /Crafted with care since 1937, Stuckey's Old Time Peanut Brittle is Delicious & Nostalgic! Hand Crafted with Real Butter & Vanilla these del...
View full details$5.99| /Sold out -
Stuckeys Candied Kettle Glazed Pecans 4oz Bag
Stuckey's Corporation$7.99| /Crafted with care since 1937, Stuckey's Toasted Pecans are made from small batch, Georgia-grown pecans. These world-famous pecans are handcrafted a...
View full details$7.99| / -
Christmas Terrys Milk Chocolate Orange 5.53oz
Carambar & Co$4.99| /Send holiday cheer with this classic French treat! Manufactured by Carambar & Co. Terrys Milk Chocolate Orange is perfect for sharing—the iconi...
View full details$4.99| /Sold out -
Gilliam Old Fashioned Horehound Drops 4.5oz bag
Quality Candy Company$1.99| /Experience the flavor of a time less traditional American confectionery with Gilliam Old Fashioned Horehound Drops. Manufactured since 1927, this b...
View full details$1.99| / -
Taffy Town Salt Water Taffy Assorted 4.5oz bag
Taffy Town Inc.Original price $2.99Current price $2.49| /Since 1916 Taffy Town Inc. has been producing Gourmet Salt Water Taffy with their unique recipe using egg whites to create a whipped nougat style t...
View full detailsOriginal price $2.99Current price $2.49| / -
Smarties Tropical 5oz Bag
Smarties Candy Co.$2.39| /Smarties originated in New Jersey in 1949 and continue as a family-owned business to this day! Billions of classic smarties rolls are created each ...
View full details$2.39| / -
Reeds Candy Butterscotch 6.25oz bag
Iconic Candy Co.$3.49| /Beloved since they first debuted in 1883, Reed’s roll candies have delighted loyal fans with the incredibly bold flavor that's packed into each ind...
View full details$3.49| / -
Nik L Nip Sour Wax bottle 4 pack or 18ct box
Charms Candy Co.from $1.99| /Just like the original but now with Cray Baby Sour juice inside! Bite em' Drink em' Chew em'!
from $1.99| / -
Tootsie Roll Mini Bites 3.5oz box or 12ct case
Tootsie Roll Industriesfrom $1.49| /Tootsie Roll Mini bites are a new way to enjoy your favorite Tootsie treat! Each Tootsie Roll Mini Bite starts with a delicious chewy Tootsie Roll ...
View full detailsfrom $1.49| / -
Pez Cola Candy Refills 8ct Pack
Pez Candy, Inc.Original price $2.39Current price $2.00| /Founded in 1927 in Austria, Pez has grown into one of the largest internationally recognized brands in the history of candy! This pack contains 8 i...
View full detailsOriginal price $2.39Current price $2.00| /Sold out -
Pez Assorted SOUR Fruit Refills 8ct Pack
Pez Candy, Inc.Original price $2.39Current price $2.00| /Founded in 1927 in Austria, Pez has grown into one of the largest internationally recognized brands in the history of candy! This Assorted SOUR fru...
View full detailsOriginal price $2.39Current price $2.00| / -
Gustaf's Dutch Licorice Cats 5.29oz bag
Gerrit J Verburg Co.$2.99| /Since 1876 Gustaf's Factory has produced endless varieties of licorice! These are for the licorice lover that likes it nice and Firm with a delicio...
View full details$2.99| / -
Gustaf's Dutch Licorice Double Salt 5.29oz bag
Gerrit J Verburg Co.$2.99| /Since 1876 Gustaf's Factory has produced endless varieties of licorice! These are for the licorice lover that likes it Salty! This Licorice will hi...
View full details$2.99| / -
Gustaf's Dutch Licorice Beagles 5.29oz bag
Gerrit J Verburg Co.$2.99| /Since 1876 Gustaf's Factory has produced endless varieties of licorice! These super soft Black Licorice Beagles are the perfect treat. rest assured...
View full details$2.99| / -
Cow Tales Honey Bun 1oz pack or 36ct box
Goetzes Candy Co.from $0.59| /Chewy caramel rope with a delicious cream center, one bite of this cows tail and it will have you Moo-ing for more!
from $0.59| / -
Paintball Pops MEGA Assorted 4.94oz Pop or 12ct Box
SP Enterprises, Inc.from $1.99| /Step right up and get ready for a taste explosion with our MEGA Paintball Pops! Double the size of the original paintball pops, These MEGA jawbreak...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Paintball Pops Assorted 2.12oz Pop or 24ct Box
SP Enterprises, Inc.from $1.99| /Step right up and get ready for a taste explosion with our Paintball Pops! These jawbreakers on a stick will send your taste buds on a wild adventu...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Rock Candy Sticks Assorted 36ct Box
SP Enterprises, Inc.$39.75| /Espeez Old Fashioned Rock Candy on a Stick! Just like you remember from the good old days! These delicious candies carry approximately 22 grams of ...
View full details$39.75| / -
Hot Lips Cinnamon Rolls or 100ct Jar
SP Enterprises, Inc.from $0.50| /From the makers of Money Mints, Introducing "Hot Lips" Cinnamon Flavor Candies! Turn up the heat with each piece that's jam packed with sizzling ci...
View full detailsfrom $0.50| / -
Money Mints Rolls or 100ct Jar
SP Enterprises, Inc.from $0.50| /Indulge in these "money mints" that will have you feeling like a million bucks! Each wrapper is designed to look like a 100 dollar bill, while the ...
View full detailsfrom $0.50| / -
Rose Pops Assorted 1.2oz Pop or 24ct Box
SP Enterprises, Inc.from $1.59| /Spread the love (and deliciousness) with 3D Rose Pops! These 1.2oz pops come in an assorted 24ct box, perfect for sharing with your loved ones. A s...
View full detailsfrom $1.59| / -
Dice Pops Assorted 1.16oz Pop or 24ct Box
SP Enterprises, Inc.from $1.79| /Roll the dice and treat yourself to a deliciously playful sensation with Dice Pops! These 3D Vegas Style lollipops come in a 1.16oz pop or a 24ct b...
View full detailsfrom $1.79| / -
Dice Pops Red 1.16oz Pop or 24ct Box
SP Enterprises, Inc.from $1.79| /Roll the dice and treat yourself to a deliciously playful sensation with Dice Pops! These 3D Vegas Style lollipops come in a 1.16oz pop or a 24ct b...
View full detailsfrom $1.79| / -
Tie Dye Cube Pops .71oz Pop or 24ct Box
SP Enterprises, Inc.from $0.79| /Espeez Tie Dye Cube Pops! Just like the Old school Square Shooters, This version of Cube Pops are proudly manufactured in the USA, Showcasing some ...
View full detailsfrom $0.79| / -
Cinnamon Cube Pops .74oz Pop or 24ct Box
SP Enterprises, Inc.from $0.79| /Espeez Old Fashioned Cinnamon Cube Pops! Just like the Old school Square Shooters, Cinnamon Cube Pops are proudly manufactured in the USA, packed w...
View full detailsfrom $0.79| / -
Cinna Pix Cinnamon Toothpicks 15ct Pack or 24ct Box
SP Enterprises, Inc.from $1.49| /Espeez Old Fashioned Cinnamon Toothpicks! Amazing quality Birch Hardwood toothpicks loaded with your favorite cinnamon flavor!
from $1.49| /