Nostalgic
Filters
-
Caramel Creams Original 1.9oz pack or 20ct box
Goetzes Candy Co.from $1.59| /Also known as Bulls-Eyes, The original Goetze's Caramel Creams, soft chewy caramel with a smooth cream center!
from $1.59| / -
Brach's Nips Hard Candy Butter Rum 3.25oz bag
Ferrara Candy Company$2.39| /Originally created by Pearson Candy Company of Culver City California. The company started in business back in 1928 by Barney Pearson. The NIPS lin...
View full details$2.39| / -
Cadbury Curly Wurly .75oz bar
Cadbury$2.19| /Cadbury is a multinational British Candy company that was founded back in 1824! For almost 200 years the confectionery giant has been producing so...
View full details$2.19| / -
Smarties Lollies single pop or 120ct jar
Smarties Candy Co.from $0.25| /Smarties candy originated back in 1949 in New Jersey, still family owned & operated to this day! Smarties Lollies, Your Favorite Smarties candy...
View full detailsfrom $0.25| / -
Sweetarts Original 5oz box or 12ct case
Ferrara Candy Companyfrom $1.99| /The Original Sweetart Rolls, deliciously sweet and just the right amount of tantalizing Tart for your taste buds. Yet another classic from the form...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Sky Bar 1.5oz bar or 24ct box
Skybar Candy Companyfrom $2.79| /Sky Bar is an American candy bar that was introduced by Necco in 1938, discontinued in 2018, and reintroduced in 2019 by the Sky Bar Confectionary ...
View full detailsfrom $2.79| /Sold out -
Rocky Road Dark Chocolate with Sea Salt 1.82oz bar or 24ct box
Annabelle Candy Cofrom $1.99| /Instead of the original Rocky Road Bar that was made with Handmade Milk Chocolate poured over an amazing Marshmallow Mound with Roasted Cashews, th...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Chocolate Ice Cubes 60ct box
R. L. Alberts and Sons Inc.$24.75| /Ice Cubes are little squares of wonderfully smooth milk chocolate from Germany. They are just the right size for an afternoon energy boost!***IMPOR...
View full details$24.75| / -
Whirly Rainbow 3 inch Lollipop 1.5oz
Adams & Brooks Inc.$2.99| /The Original Whirly Pop, these fruit flavored swirled rope pops are hand made. They actually take the candy while its semi soft and hand twist the ...
View full details$2.99| / -
Ovation Break Apart Orange Dark Chocolate 5.53oz box or 12ct case
Sweetworks Confections LLC.from $4.99| /Break a Parts, formerly known as Florida Tropics. These delicious candies are also fun, so 1st you grab the whole thing and slam it on the counter ...
View full detailsfrom $4.99| /Sold out -
Ovation Break Apart Raspberry Milk Chocolate 5.53oz box or 12ct case
Sweetworks Confections LLC.from $4.99| /Break a Parts, formerly known as Florida Tropics. These delicious candies are also fun, so 1st you grab the whole thing and slam it on the counter ...
View full detailsfrom $4.99| /Sold out -
Ovation Break Apart Orange Milk Chocolate 5.53oz box or 12ct case
Sweetworks Confections LLC.from $4.99| /Break a Parts, formerly known as Florida Tropics. These delicious candies are also fun, so 1st you grab the whole thing and slam it on the counter ...
View full detailsfrom $4.99| /Sold out -
Sno Caps 3.1oz Box or 15ct Case
Ferrero USA Inc.from $1.99| /Originally Produced by Blumenthal Chocolate Co. back in 1920. Sno caps are a delicious semi-sweet dark chocolate drop with white candy nonpareils o...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Pop Rocks Crackling Gum .33oz pack or 24ct box
Pop Rocks, Inc.from $1.29| /Pop Rocks, Poppin Since 1970! These Carbonated Crystals were so popular when introduced that an urban legend was born stating that if you consumed ...
View full detailsfrom $1.29| / -
Pumpkin Seeds 9 gram pack or 36ct box
Zenobia Co.from $0.50| /Pumpkin Seeds Indian Brand 9gram pack.
from $0.50| / -
Tootsie Roll 2.25oz bar or 36ct box
Tootsie Roll Industriesfrom $1.79| /As the iconic treat that launched America’s favorite candy company, Tootsie Roll, offers a perfectly-balanced cocoa taste, lined with a subtle, fru...
View full detailsfrom $1.79| / -
Claeys Old Fashioned Hard Candy Drops 6oz bag Horehound
Claey's Candy Inc$1.99| /Enjoy the sweet taste of Claey's hard candy drops! For over a century, this family owned, 3rd generation companies candy has been hand crafted in t...
View full details$1.99| / -
Dr Pepper Cotton Candy 3.1oz bag
Taste of Nature$3.99| /The name "Dr. Pepper" was first used commercially in 1885. It was introduced nationally in the United States at the 1904 Louisiana Purchase Expedit...
View full details$3.99| /Sold out -
Cow Tales Strawberry 1oz pack or 36ct box
Goetzes Candy Co.from $0.59| /Chewy strawberry S-moo-thie flavored caramel rope with a delicious cream center, one bite of this cows tail and it will have you Moo-ing for more! ...
View full detailsfrom $0.59| / -
Brach's Nips Hard Candy Caramel 3.25oz bag
Ferrara Candy Company$2.39| /Originally created by Pearson Candy Company of Culver City California. The company started in business back in 1928 by Barney Pearson. The NIPS lin...
View full details$2.39| / -
Smarties Love Hearts 7oz bag
Smarties Candy Co.$2.39| /Smarties originated in New Jersey in 1949 and continue as a family-owned business to this day! Billions of classic smarties rolls are created each ...
View full details$2.39| / -
Smarties Candy Necklace 2.9oz bag
Smarties Candy Co.$2.29| /Smarties originated in New Jersey in 1949 and continue as a family-owned business to this day! Billions of classic smarties rolls are created each ...
View full details$2.29| / -
Smarties Giant 1oz roll or 36ct box
Smarties Candy Co.from $0.69| /We call these the goldy locks Smarties, Not the small smarties, Not the MEGA Smarties, but these Giant Smarties are Juuuusssssst Right! Also they t...
View full detailsfrom $0.69| / -
Mike and Ike Tropical Typhoon 4.25oz box or 12ct case
Just Born Inc.from $1.89| /Mike and Ike Tropical Typhoon, same exact texture as the original but be prepared for a tropical explosion for your taste buds with flavors of Kiwi...
View full detailsfrom $1.89| /