Nostalgic
Filters
-
Lifesavers Swirled Lollipops 7.1oz bag
Spangler Candy Co.Original price $4.99Current price $4.00| /Swirl pops are back! Gone for over a decade these delicious cream swirled pops licensed by Mars Wrigley are now being produced by Spangler Candy Co...
View full detailsOriginal price $4.99Current price $4.00| / -
Anderson's Red Peanut Rounder 2.25oz pack or 30ct box
Anderson Candy Cofrom $1.19| /A Staple Item in The South West! Anderson Candy uses only the finest roasted peanuts in every rounder they produce!
from $1.19| / -
Sugar Babies Caramel Apple 4.75oz box or 12ct case
Charms Candy Co.from $1.99| /Enjoy bite-sized, milk caramel goodness with Sugar Babies, America's favorite chewy caramel treat. Introduced in 1935 in response to the success of...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Candy Cigarettes Original 24ct Box or .72oz Pack
World Confectionsfrom $0.79| /The Original being produced since the late 19th Century! It has been a classic candy item and a bit of a controversary item as well. Agree or disag...
View full detailsfrom $0.79| / -
Sugar Daddy 1.7oz pop or 24ct box
Tootsie Roll Industriesfrom $1.99| /Enjoy satisfying, milk caramel goodness with Sugar Daddy, America's oldest and most popular milk caramel lollipop. Slow-cooked caramel, packed in n...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Gimbals Cinnamon Lovers 7oz bag
Jelly Belly Candy Company$3.99| /Gimbals Candy since 1898. These Cinnamon Lovers are heart shaped gourmet jelly beans that are sure to delight your taste buds and sizzle your sense...
View full details$3.99| / -
Fun Dip .43oz pack or 48ct box
Ferrara Candy Companyfrom $0.59| /Originally called Lik-m-aid by Sunline Brands (formerly Willy Wonka Brands) This amazing iconic candy goes back to 1959! A product of Pixy Stix, Li...
View full detailsfrom $0.59| / -
Necco Wafers Original 2oz pack or 24ct box
Spangler Candy Co.from $1.89| /Originally manufactured in 1847 by Necco (New England Confectionery Company in Massachusetts) After Necco, the oldest know USA Candy Manufacture cl...
View full detailsfrom $1.89| / -
Abba Zaba Snack Size Bars 4.4oz bag or 12ct Case
Annabelle Candy Cofrom $2.99| /A Soft n Chewy Taffy with a delicious roasted Peanut Butter Filled Center, Abba Zaba May just be your only friend, If you don't share nicely!
from $2.99| / -
Smarties Candy Necklace .74oz pack or 24ct box
Smarties Candy Co.from $0.69| /The Original Classic, this is a staple candy in American confectionery, delicious candy beads strung on a one size fits most elastic string, wear i...
View full detailsfrom $0.69| / -
Bit O Honey 4.2oz bag or 12ct Case
Spangler Candy Companyfrom $2.79| /With Real Honey & Almond Bits blended into taffy, Bit-O-Honey is an American Icon for almost 100 years! Originally Introduced in 1924 by Schutt...
View full detailsfrom $2.79| / -
Tart n Tinys 1.5oz pack or 24ct box
Leaf Brands LLCfrom $1.99| /Gone for over a decade, these amazing little candy bites are back! In a variety of flavors, get ready to pucker up buttercup!
from $1.99| /Sold out -
Big Hunk Snack Size 4.4oz bag or 12ct case
Annabelle Candy Cofrom $2.99| /Just like the original classic, this bag is packed with Big Hunks of Honey Sweetened chewy Nougat with whole Fresh Roasted Peanuts, that you know a...
View full detailsfrom $2.99| / -
Pop Rocks Strawberry .33oz pack or 24ct box
Pop Rocks, Inc.from $1.29| /Pop Rocks, Poppin Since 1970! These Carbonated Crystals were so popular when introduced that an urban legend was born stating that if you consumed ...
View full detailsfrom $1.29| / -
Whatchamacallit 1.6oz bar or 36ct Box
Hershey Chocolate Companyfrom $1.99| /Its delicious, what should we call it? Peanut Crisp Bar? Chocolate Caramel Crisp? PCC Bar? Choco caramello crispy peanut bar? What ever you want to...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Caramel Creams Oreo 1.9oz pack
Goetzes Candy Co.$1.59| /Also known as Bulls-Eyes, The original Goetze's Caramel Creams, soft chewy caramel with a smooth cream center, but the Oreo cookie version!
$1.59| /Sold out -
Zotz Blue Raspberry Orange Grape 4pc strip or 48ct box
Andre Prost Inc.from $0.69| /Since 1970 Zotz have been bringing the FIZZ Power direct from Italy! This box contains Blue Raspberry Orange and Grape Fizz filled hard candies! Ov...
View full detailsfrom $0.69| / -
Rocky Road 1.82oz bar or 24ct box
Annabelle Candy Cofrom $1.99| /The Original Rocky Road Bar with Handmade Milk Chocolate poured over an amazing Marshmallow Mound with Roasted Cashews, this bar is out of bounds! ...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Big Hunk 1.8oz bar or 24ct box
Annabelle Candy Cofrom $1.99| /Behold, A Big Hunk of Honey Sweetened chewy Nougat with whole Roasted Peanuts. I will definitely take a full box please!
from $1.99| / -
Wacky Wafers 1.2oz pack or 24ct box
Leaf Brands LLCfrom $1.99| /Gone for over a decade, these wacky wafers of sugary sweetness are back! Keeping true to the original flavors, packaging and taste these are a clas...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| /Sold out -
Pop Rocks Extreme SOUR .24oz pack or 48ct box
Pop Rocks, Inc.from $0.45| /Pop Rocks, Poppin Since 1970! These Carbonated Crystals were so popular when introduced that an urban legend was born stating that if you consumed ...
View full detailsfrom $0.45| /Sold out -
Pop Rocks Blue Raspberry .33oz pack or 24ct box
Pop Rocks, Inc.from $1.29| /Pop Rocks, Poppin Since 1970! These Carbonated Crystals were so popular when introduced that an urban legend was born stating that if you consumed ...
View full detailsfrom $1.29| / -
Gold Mine Gum 2oz pack or 24ct box
SP Enterprises, Inc.from $1.99| /Unearth a sweet surprise with Gold Mine Gum! These classic burlap sacks are filled with "nugget" bubble gum that's sure to satisfy your cravings. P...
View full detailsfrom $1.99| / -
Sugar Daddy Mini pop or 48ct box
Tootsie Roll Industriesfrom $0.40| /Enjoy small satisfying, milk caramel goodness with Sugar Daddy, America's oldest and most popular milk caramel lollipop. Slow-cooked caramel, packe...
View full detailsfrom $0.40| /